The Wanamaker is a good place for value. Given its location on Walnut Street, it is a straight shot to Penn's campus (if you are a student) through bus or Uber - I'm on campus in less than 10 minutes door to door. However, there has been a lot of construction around Philly and this block is no different. There is usually a lot of drilling by the city's water department close by which is noisy but tolerable given the Wanamaker's thick windows. Also, the Wanamaker has been undergoing a renovation project with unclear timelines for completion. This is noisy and disruptive and management does not seem to be tackling that project well. For example, we have not received keys to any of our amenities even though the lounges were constructed months ago. However, other maintenance issues (e.g., lights not working, bathroom issues, A/C) are resolved in an incredibly timely manner, usually with 1-2 hour turnaround times or less.

So, consider living here if you like space, quiet, sunlight, and a direct shot to Penn's campus. If you value amenities, social community in your building, and crisply run management, consider another building in the Rittenhouse area.

The apartment is very conveniently located for Penn students. It’s also nice to have a pool and a fitness center. Great views.

Great location

I love my apartment itself. I think the gym is somewhat lacking and it's unfortunate that it doesn't have common space that we can use (e.g., lounge). That being said, it is decently affordable for a 1BR luxury high-rise, so can't complain!

Wanamaker House is in a great location - 2 blocks from Rittenhouse Square, close to tons of restaurants and bars, and an easy walk or bus ride to Penn's campus. The 2-bedroom units have huge living spaces and big windows, and having 2 en-suite bathrooms is great. The front desk staff are generally friendly and helpful.
The downside is that the gym is quite outdated and there is no good common space. The hospitality suite is very old and can only be used with a reservation / payment. They are planning a renovation of the common space in the next 1-2 years, so that may change.

Excellent location and value

From the old buildings its one of the best. The gym is not bad and you don't feel it's such a big building. Apartments inside might be old but they are very functional, spacious and comfortable. I am very happy living here.

Benefits of a walk-up townhouse, plus the management staff of a large apartment complex. Amenities are not as good as some of the other more modern apartment complexes in the area.

Convenient location, decent amenities, love the doormen

Excellent place to live for UPenn students or young professionals that work in the city center area. It's a walkable distance to dozens of restaurants, bars, and schools. The staff are always friendly and keep the place secure 24/7.

There is a small gym upstairs (think small hotel sized) with a few treadmills, ellipticals, and small machines. The pool is only available from May through September, so I've yet to enjoy it.

Your stay at the Wanamaker may be a bit dependent on your unit. Some are newly furnished (ours is not), so that's a plus! But, it likely means your rent will be a bit higher.